When you see those shocking TV shows about people living in homes completely buried under mountains of stuff, you might wonder how anyone could live that way. But new research reveals that hoarding isn’t what most people think it is—and it doesn’t start with someone just being messy or disorganized. Scientists have been digging deeper into the roots of hoarding behavior, and what they’ve discovered challenges everything we thought we knew about this misunderstood condition.
Hoarding Starts Way Earlier Than You Think
Research has shattered the myth that hoarding suddenly appears in adulthood when people get overwhelmed by life. Scientists studying adults with hoarding behaviors discovered that most can trace their earliest symptoms back to ages 11 to 15, right in the middle school years, when kids are dealing with academic pressure and figuring out who they are.
Detailed interviews with adults who hoard revealed that many formed powerful emotional connections to their belongings during childhood. Unlike typical kids who might have a few special toys or keepsakes, these children felt distressed about throwing away even ordinary items like broken toys, old homework papers, or worn-out clothes.
Each possession carried deep meaning for these kids. Old receipts represented memories of memorable outings. Broken gadgets held potential for future repair projects. Even seemingly worthless items told stories or connected to specific emotions that felt too important to lose.
University transitions often intensified these behaviors, whether students were starting college or graduating into adult responsibilities. One study participant linked his hoarding escalation to losing access to student services and the security that institutional support provided during significant life transitions.
Parents Often Make Things Worse Without Realizing It
Many adults who hoard remember painful childhood moments when parents threw away their possessions without permission or pressured them to get rid of what adults considered “junk.” While parents usually have good intentions when they clean out kids’ rooms or organize their belongings, this approach often backfires spectacularly.
When children feel intense emotional connections to objects, forced disposal can create lasting psychological wounds. Instead of learning healthy attachment patterns, kids may become more secretive about their collections or develop stronger hoarding behaviors as defensive responses.
Parents who don’t understand the emotional significance these items hold for their children often dismiss their distress as stubbornness or materialism. But research shows that children who hoard aren’t being difficult—they’re experiencing genuine emotional pain when forced to discard meaningful possessions.
Family dynamics around possessions during childhood can set patterns that persist throughout life. Children who learn to hide their attachments or feel ashamed of their emotional connections to objects may struggle with healthy decision-making about belongings well into adulthood.
It’s All About Emotional Connections, Not Stuff
The heart of hoarding lies in unusually intense emotional relationships with objects that extend far beyond what most people experience. While non-hoarders might feel sentimental about family heirlooms or gifts from loved ones, people who hoard develop meaningful connections to much broader categories of items.
Everyday objects become vessels for memory, emotion, and identity. Old magazines represent potential learning opportunities. Broken appliances hold promise for future repair projects. Even expired coupons carry memories of shopping trips or represent financial security through potential savings.
People who hoard don’t see piles of junk—they see collections of meaningful items that connect them to experiences, people, and possibilities. Each object tells a story, and discarding it feels like losing part of their personal history or future opportunities.
Understanding this emotional dimension explains why traditional organizing approaches often fail. You can’t solve hoarding by simply cleaning up or providing better storage solutions because the issue isn’t about space or organization—it’s about the deep emotional significance people assign to their possessions.
Life Stress Often Triggers Hoarding Behaviors
While some people show hoarding tendencies from early childhood, others develop these behaviors later in response to specific stressors or significant life changes. Research identifies several common triggers that can either initiate hoarding or make existing tendencies much worse.
Major losses like the death of loved ones, divorce, or job termination can destabilize people’s sense of control and security. During these vulnerable periods, holding onto possessions may feel like a way to maintain stability when everything else feels uncertain.
Health challenges, both physical and mental, can overwhelm people’s ability to manage their belongings effectively. Depression, anxiety, and cognitive processing difficulties can make decision-making about possessions feel impossibly complex and emotionally draining.
Moving to new homes, retirement, or other significant life transitions can trigger hoarding behaviors even in people who previously managed their possessions well. These changes disrupt established routines and coping mechanisms, making possession management feel overwhelming.
Scientists Developed a New Way to Understand Hoarding
Traditional approaches to hoarding focused mainly on individual psychology and behavior patterns, but newer research takes a broader view that considers life circumstances and environmental factors. The “struggling to manage” model shifts attention from personal deficits to situational challenges that make possession management difficult.
This framework recognizes that hoarding behaviors often emerge when people face multiple stressors simultaneously or lack adequate support systems to help them cope with life demands. Instead of asking why someone keeps so much stuff, this approach examines what’s happening in their life that makes letting feel impossible.
The model includes scenarios like managing chronic illness while caring for aging parents, dealing with job loss during housing instability, or navigating multiple family crises in short periods. These overwhelming circumstances can make even basic household management feel insurmountable.
This perspective emphasizes compassion over judgment by recognizing that hoarding behaviors often represent understandable responses to genuinely difficult life situations rather than personal failings or character flaws.
Early Help Makes a Huge Difference
Hoarding exists on a spectrum, and early intervention can prevent behaviors from escalating into dangerous living conditions that threaten health and safety. Recognizing warning signs during childhood or early adulthood creates opportunities for support before hoarding becomes overwhelming.
Children who show intense attachment to possessions need understanding rather than forced disposal of their belongings. Teaching kids healthy ways to process emotions and make decisions about possessions works better than shaming them for their attachments.
Adult intervention can also be highly effective when it addresses underlying emotional needs rather than just focusing on decluttering. Cognitive behavioral therapy, specifically designed for hoarding, helps people develop skills for managing their emotional relationships with possessions.
Community support groups and educational programs help reduce the shame and isolation that often accompany hoarding behaviors. When people understand that they’re not alone and that help is available, they’re more likely to seek support before their situations become critical.
The Real Problem Isn’t the Stuff
Successful hoarding intervention requires looking beyond the clutter to understand the human experiences underneath. Each pile of possessions represents emotions, memories, fears, and hopes that deserve respect and careful attention.
People who hoard aren’t lazy, dirty, or uncaring about their living conditions. They’re often intelligent, sensitive individuals who’ve developed coping mechanisms that once served important emotional needs but eventually became problematic.
Treating hoarding effectively means addressing trauma, grief, anxiety, depression, and other underlying psychological factors that drive the need to hold onto possessions. Without addressing these root causes, decluttering efforts typically fail because the emotional drivers remain unchanged.
Family members and friends can best help by offering emotional support and understanding rather than focusing solely on cleaning up. Judgment and criticism usually make hoarding behaviors worse by increasing shame and defensive reactions.
Breaking Down Stigma Helps Everyone
Media portrayals of hoarding often emphasize the most extreme cases, creating public perception that hoarding always involves dangerous living conditions and complete inability to function. These sensationalized depictions increase stigma and make people less likely to seek help when they recognize hoarding behaviors in themselves or loved ones.
Reality involves a much broader spectrum of hoarding behaviors, from mild difficulty discarding items to severe accumulation that threatens health and safety. Many people who hoard function well in other areas of their lives and may successfully hide their struggles for years.
Reducing stigma requires public education about hoarding as a treatable mental health condition rather than a personal choice or character flaw. When communities understand hoarding better, they can provide more effective support and resources for affected families.
Healthcare providers, social workers, and other professionals need training to recognize hoarding behaviors and respond with appropriate interventions rather than judgment or oversimplified solutions.
My Personal RX on Understanding and Supporting Hoarding
As a physician who has encountered patients struggling with hoarding behaviors throughout my career, I’ve learned that this condition requires the same compassion and evidence-based treatment we provide for any other health challenge. When families ask me about hoarding behaviors in children or adults, I emphasize that shaming or forcing people to discard possessions typically makes the problem worse rather than better. Understanding the emotional roots of hoarding helps us respond with empathy rather than frustration, creating opportunities for healing rather than increased distress.
- Recognize early warning signs in children: Pay attention to unusual distress when discarding items, intense emotional attachments to everyday objects, or difficulty making decisions about possessions during childhood years.
- Respond with understanding rather than forced cleanup: When children show hoarding behaviors, focus on addressing their emotional needs and teaching healthy coping skills rather than simply removing their possessions.
- Support mental health during life transitions: Use stress management techniques, counseling, and social support during moves, losses, or other major changes that can trigger hoarding behaviors.
- Maintain gut-brain health for better emotional regulation: Consider MindBiotic supplements containing probiotics and adaptogens that support the connection between digestive health and emotional balance.
- Prepare meals that support mental clarity: Use recipes from Mindful Meals cookbook that provide brain-supporting nutrients for better decision-making and emotional regulation during stressful periods.
- Seek professional help for underlying mental health conditions: Address depression, anxiety, trauma, and other psychological factors that often contribute to hoarding behaviors through appropriate therapy and treatment.
- Build strong social support networks: Maintain connections with family, friends, and community resources that can provide emotional support during difficult periods when hoarding behaviors might emerge.
- Practice gradual decluttering when appropriate: Work slowly and respectfully with professional guidance rather than attempting dramatic cleanups that can overwhelm and traumatize people who hoard.
- Focus on safety rather than perfection: Prioritize creating safe living conditions and functional spaces rather than expecting complete organization or minimalism from people who struggle with hoarding.
- Educate yourself and others about hoarding realities: Learn about hoarding as a mental health condition to reduce stigma and increase understanding in your family and community.
Sources:
Nakao, T., & Kanba, S. (2019). Pathophysiology and treatment of hoarding disorder. Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences, 73(7), 370–375. https://doi.org/10.1111/pcn.12853
Subscribe to Ask Dr. Nandi YouTube Channel
